Home

Policy

Returns policy

Items that don’t meet our condition standard are not eligible for payment. Rejected items can be returned if you provide a prepaid return shipping label within 2 business days after payment is issued. Otherwise, they will be recycled.

Rejected items can be returned

Rejected items are not eligible for payment. If you would like them returned, you must provide a prepaid return shipping label within 2 business days after payment is issued. If we do not receive a return label within that time, the rejected items will be recycled.

After you ship

What happens when we receive your box

  1. 01

    Inspection

    Every item is checked against our condition standards.

  2. 02

    Sorting

    Items are separated into those that meet the standard and those that don't.

Then one of two things

Meets the standard

You get paid

Payment is processed using the method you selected at checkout — PayPal, Venmo, or check by mail — within 2 business days of inspection.

Doesn’t meet the standard

Rejected item

The item is not paid for. You may have it returned by providing a prepaid return shipping label within 2 business days after payment is issued. Otherwise, it will be recycled.

The short version

General condition standards

Acceptable

  • In good working condition, fully functional
  • Minor wear from normal use
  • Complete with essential components and original cases or cover artwork when applicable
  • Clean and odor-free

Not acceptable

  • Writing or marker stains on discs, cases, or artwork
  • Damaged, broken, or non-functional items
  • Water damage, stains, or mold
  • Strong odors (smoke, mildew, and similar)
  • Missing essential components
  • Excessive wear that affects functionality

This is the summary. The full list — including format exclusions, ex-library and ex-rental copies, and category-specific rules — lives on the condition guidelines page.

See the full condition guidelines

Not sure about an item?

Ask us before you ship it. It’s much easier to answer a question now than to explain a rejected item later.

Contact support